Patient in the Palliative Care Ward getting morphine
Even before we got to Malawi, I knew that we were going to be spending a decent amount of time in the Palliate Care Unit, as we were supposed to work on DataPall and introduce a new morphine dosing system (Jesal did a post on it!). Thinking that I would obviously write a blog post on Palliative Care, and that I pretty much already knew why Palliative Care was so important in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), I started writing up a draft back in the comfort of the States. I began the post by throwing around a couple of HIV/AIDS statistics—like how almost 11% of the Malawian population has been diagnosed with the disease [1]—and then about how the incidence of Cervical Cancer in SSA is among the highest in the world [2]. Then I would give a little background about how the expanding field of Palliative Care—the field dedicated to the relief of suffering—was primarily due to the unfortunately high burden of HIV/AIDS and cancer.
Fortunately, I got a bit distracted/ lazy and decided to just stop writing at the introduction. Because fast forward almost two months and I now have a very different view about Palliative Care, at least how it is conducted at St. Gabe’s. Like I said, when I first stepped foot into the Palliative Care Unit, I was expecting it to be almost entirely cases related to HIV/AIDS and cancer. And while there were many, many cases related to both pathologies, the unit’s patients represented a much more diverse spectrum of diseases.
Heart Failure in Africa!?
Perhaps one of the most surprising findings was the high rate of Congestive Cardiac Failure (CCF). In fact, CCF has the distinction of being the single highest diagnosis for St. Gabe’s Palliative Care Unit (at least since DataPall was implemented 2 years ago). CCF occurs when the heart is no longer strong enough to pump all the blood that is rushing into it, so blood begins to pool up behind it—fluid then begins to accumulate in the legs, abdomen and lungs (depending on what side of the heart failed). CCF is an extremely difficult disease to live with, has a tendency to worsen over time and has a high mortality rate.
I was especially surprised at the high number of cardiovascular patients in palliative care because we’re told that heart disease is a distinctively Western problem. Heart failure is one of the so-called ‘lifestyle’ diseases, caused primarily by hypertension, which coincides with the high salt, high calorie, sedentary western lifestyle.
DataPall report for Outpatient Diagnosis for the past year. CCF is the highest single diagnosis in the ward, and CVA has a surprisingly large presence as well.
However, while Malawian citizens will probably not develop hypertension at the same rate as Americans, if someone here does develop hypertension, it tends to go undiagnosed and untreated. Untreated hypertension can lead to horrible sounding things like heart disease, stroke and organ failure (including heart failure). So a lot of the CCF patients first come in here with the characteristic symptoms such as troubled breathing and swollen legs, but when their blood pressure is taken, it often turns out to be ridiculously high (I’m talking over 200/120).
Preventable (but Hard to Treat) Disease
As far as my studies have suggested to me, it seems like the only treatments for heart failure are ventricular assist devices (LVADs/RVADs), a full heart transplant, or an artificial heart (if transplantation is not feasible). These options are not feasible for many western patients, not event to mention Malawian patients. Thus, the majority of CCF patients are referred to palliative care for symptom management.
This is a disheartening trend, as hypertension (and then heart failure) is well known to be very, very preventable with changes in lifestyle. And while I know this is anecdotal, I’ve heard from two different people (a palliative care doctor and a community health worker) that even a simple reduction of dietary sodium is usually enough to bring their blood pressure back down to manageable levels.
More Data, More Diagnostics and More Prevention
There is very little data on the prevalence of heart disease in Africa, as it tends to be both poorly diagnosed in the community and very low on the priorities of international health organizations. This is understandable, given the huge health challenges that the continent faces with HIV/AIDS, TB, malaria and many other diseases. However, even the sparse data suggests that our observations here could be generalized to much of the rest of SSA [3]. I never thought I’d say this, but I now strongly believe that it is imperative to raise awareness of hypertension and heart disease in Africa.
We need to catch the attention of both NGOs and governments so that (1) better data can be collected to help us better understand the issue and (2) more cases of hypertension can be diagnosed early, and then appropriate lifestyle interventions can be implemented. We need not develop the same huge cardiovascular research network as in the west for this problem—it does not seem like the newest expensive medications or devices are needed in this case. What is needed is attractively cheap—just diagnosis with a simple stethoscope + cuff, and inexpensive lifestyle interventions like cutting out dietary salt and increasing physical activity.
But what other surprising health trends could be lying in Africa simply because of the lack of good data?
[1] www.unicef.org/infobycountry/malawi_statistics.html
[2] http://www.afro.who.int/en/clusters-a-programmes/dpc/non-communicable-diseases-managementndm/programme-components/cancer/cervical-cancer/2810-cervical-cancer.html
[3] Opie LH. Heart Disease in Africa. The Lancet 2006; 368:9534.
Quote of the Day
“Guys, I think I accidentally killed the lizard!” – Jesal (really, really distressed)